Recently we at The Highway Star were contacted by a person who was concerned that one of the comments on our site contains an untrue statement and asked if the comment in question could be removed. We refused to remove it, for a variety of good reasons, and offered our help in getting in touch with the author of the comment to sort things out.
Which got me thinking…
After our Bullets flying editorial was published, some of you started complaining that “if you have nothing good to say, say nothing” contradicts freedom of speech. No, it does not.
With freedom comes responsibility. Responsibility for your own words, for what you say. It doesn’t matter where you say it. It’s all the same Internet. It doesn’t matter if you’re hiding behind a nickname (putting a real name to a nickname is often a lot easier than many of you might think).
And everything that you say on the Internet stays there forever. One can remove something from a web site, but no one can “unpublish” something from the Internet as a whole. Even if we decide tomorrow to close the shop and destroy all the data on The Highway Star, it will make little difference. Everything you can see on our site has already been crawled, archived and indexed by Google, Yahoo, dozens of other search engines, by the Wayback Machine, and probably by thousands, if not millions, other less obvious places on the ‘net. Repeatedly.
Bruce Schneier (a computer the computer security guru) writes about this phenomena:
Welcome to the future, where everything about you is saved. A future where your actions are recorded, your movements are tracked, and your conversations are no longer ephemeral. A future brought to you not by some 1984-like dystopia, but by the natural tendencies of computers to produce data.
Increasingly, you leave a trail of digital footprints throughout your day. Once you walked into a bookstore and bought a book with cash. Now you visit Amazon, and all of your browsing and purchases are recorded. You used to buy a train ticket with coins; now your electronic fare card is tied to your bank account. Your store affinity cards give you discounts; merchants use the data on them to reveal detailed purchasing patterns.
Computers are mediating conversation as well. Face-to-face conversations are ephemeral. Years ago, telephone companies might have known who you called and how long you talked, but not what you said. Today you chat in e-mail, by text message, and on social networking sites. You blog and you Twitter. These conversations – with family, friends, and colleagues – can be recorded and stored.
Note: they are being recorded and stored. Bruce wrote that piece for the BBC and probably didn’t want to scare the wide audience too much.
It used to be too expensive to save this data, but computer memory is now cheaper. Computer processing power is cheaper, too; more data is cross-indexed and correlated, and then used for secondary purposes. What was once ephemeral is now permanent.
Your future has no privacy, not because of some police-state governmental tendencies or corporate malfeasance, but because computers naturally produce data.
To which I must add that police-state governmental tendencies and corporate malfeasance don’t exactly help matters either.
Cardinal Richelieu famously said: “If one would give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest man, I would find something in them to have him hanged.” When all your words and actions can be saved for later examination, different rules have to apply.
(Go and read the whole thing, if you never paused and thought about it, it’s very illuminating. And yes, there are people who try to put a positive spin on these developments.)
Now, imagine 10 years from now your prospective employer judging you by the comments you have written on some music blog back in 2009.
We all here at The Highway Star value your privacy like our own. But the day will come when someone knocks on the door and we will no longer be able to protect you. And let’s be honest, we’re all human beings, with all the usual weaknesses. If we think your behaviour in the comments was less than commendable, we might be less motivated to fight for you.
With the lawmakers and judiciary increasingly meddling with the things they apparently do not understand, this day will come sooner rather than later. You’ll know that the day of reckoning has come when the innocent warning below our comment box changes to “You have the right to remain silent. Everything you say can and will be used against you in the court of law.” And the brave new world shall begin.
Behave yourselves, it’s in your own best interest.